+0

# is the square root of ten rational or irrational

0
252
2

is the square root of ten rational or irrational

Guest Jan 10, 2015

#1
+26399
+10

Irrational

.

Alan  Jan 10, 2015
Sort:

#1
+26399
+10

Irrational

.

Alan  Jan 10, 2015
#2
+91448
+5

Lets try and prove this.  I am going to do it by contradiction.

$$\\Assume \;\;\sqrt{10}\; is\; rational\\\\ then \;\sqrt{10}\;can\;\; be\;\; written\;\; as \;\;\dfrac{p}{q}\\ where p and q are relatively prime integers (they have no common factors)\\\\$$

$$\\\sqrt{10}=\frac{p}{q}\\\\ 10=\frac{p^2}{q^2}\\\\ p^2=10q^2\\\\ So\;\; p^2\;\; is a multiple of 10\\\\ \mbox{so p is a multiple of 10}\\\\ Let\; p=10g\\\\ (10g)^2=10q^2\\\\ 100g^2=10q^2\\\\ 10g^2=q^2\\\\ So\;\; q^2  is a multiple of 10\\\\ so q is a multiple of 10\\\\ I have discovered that p and q are both multiples of 10$$\$

Therefore p and q are not relatively prime

therefore the original statement is contradicted

therefore  $${\sqrt{{\mathtt{10}}}}$$    is irrational.

-------------------------------------------------------------

Note:

I have said that since pis a multiple of 10, p must also be a multiple of 10. WHY is so.

Well the prime factors of squared numbers must come in pairs.

Lets look at an example

$$\\What\;\; if\;\; p^2=900\\ p^2=30\times 30\\ p^2=3\times 5\times 2 \quad \times \quad 3\times 5\times 2\\ p^2=3\times 3\times 2 \times 2\times 5\times 5\\ see how the factors have to be in pairs?\\ p=3\times 2 \times 5\\$$

------

10 is the product of 2 prime numbers

Can you see how if  p^2 is a product of 10 then p must also be the product of 10?

Melody  Jan 11, 2015

### 12 Online Users

We use cookies to personalise content and ads, to provide social media features and to analyse our traffic. We also share information about your use of our site with our social media, advertising and analytics partners.  See details