+0  
 
0
150
1
avatar

Prove that √3 is a irrational number.

Guest Apr 5, 2017
Sort: 

1+0 Answers

 #1
avatar+76972 
+1

Here's one way :

 

Let us suppose that we have positive integers  a and b   such that

 

√3  = a / b     where a/b is in lowest terms  and a > b ......     square both sides

 

3  = a^2 / b^2

 

3b^2   =  a^2 

 

2b^2 + b^2   = a^2

 

2b^2   =  a^2 - b^2        (1)

 

We have three cases to consider

 

Case A   ....a and b are both even......but this is impossible because a/b would not be reduced to lowest terms if this were true since both would be divisible by 2

 

Case B  .......a is even and b is odd....but, in (1),  2b^2 is even but a^2 - b^2   is odd....and this is impossible  [Note the same result is produced if a is even and b is odd]

 

Case C ......the hardest to prove......let a, b  be odd....then we have that

 

2b^2 =  a^2  - b^2

2b^2 = (a + b) (a - b)

 

However.....if a and b are both odd......then (a + b) and (a - b) are both even....so....let (a + b)  = 2m and (a - b)  = 2n ......and we have that

 

2b^2  =  2m * 2n

2b^2  = 4mn 

b^2  = 2mn

 

But if b is odd, then so is b^2.......but 2mn is even......so this is a contradiction

 

Hence.......there are no positive integers a, b   of the same or different parity such that

 

√3  = a / b

 

 


cool cool cool

CPhill  Apr 5, 2017
edited by CPhill  Apr 5, 2017

3 Online Users

We use cookies to personalise content and ads, to provide social media features and to analyse our traffic. We also share information about your use of our site with our social media, advertising and analytics partners.  See details