+0  
 
0
314
4
avatar

Why can't I take (-1)^1/2

Guest Nov 4, 2015

Best Answer 

 #2
avatar+90996 
+10

Why can't I take (-1)^1/2

 

lets think about this.

This means

 

\(\sqrt{-1}\)

 

Now

 

\(\sqrt{25}=5\\ because\;\; 5*5 = 25\\ so\\ think\;\;about\;\; \sqrt{any\;negative\;number} \)

 

a positive * a positive = a positive

a negative * a negative = a positive

 

Mmm

you cannot multiply any real number by itself and get a negative answer.  That is impossible !!

So

\(\sqrt{-1}\)

has no real solution!!!

That is why you cannot do it!!

 

 

\(\sqrt{-1}\)

is the basis of the imaginary number system.  It is called i (or sometimes j)

 

\(i=\sqrt{-1}\)

Melody  Nov 4, 2015
Sort: 

4+0 Answers

 #1
avatar+56 
0

Try (-1)*-0.5

ChoZerr  Nov 4, 2015
 #2
avatar+90996 
+10
Best Answer

Why can't I take (-1)^1/2

 

lets think about this.

This means

 

\(\sqrt{-1}\)

 

Now

 

\(\sqrt{25}=5\\ because\;\; 5*5 = 25\\ so\\ think\;\;about\;\; \sqrt{any\;negative\;number} \)

 

a positive * a positive = a positive

a negative * a negative = a positive

 

Mmm

you cannot multiply any real number by itself and get a negative answer.  That is impossible !!

So

\(\sqrt{-1}\)

has no real solution!!!

That is why you cannot do it!!

 

 

\(\sqrt{-1}\)

is the basis of the imaginary number system.  It is called i (or sometimes j)

 

\(i=\sqrt{-1}\)

Melody  Nov 4, 2015
 #3
avatar
0

Okay super I understand, but what about \({(-1)}^{1/3}\)

 

I think that will be \(\sqrt[3]{-1}\)

You can say (-1)*(-1)*(-1) = -1, but it still says error?

Guest Nov 4, 2015
 #4
avatar+90996 
0

Yes you are right.

It is my experience that even very sophisticated calcs can't handle roots of negative numbers. 

I think Alan went into more detail on this once before. Maybe he will comment later. :/

Melody  Nov 4, 2015

8 Online Users

avatar
avatar
We use cookies to personalise content and ads, to provide social media features and to analyse our traffic. We also share information about your use of our site with our social media, advertising and analytics partners.  See details