+0

# Alan, dont fail me this time

+4
272
7
+310

Let F be a field. A matrix =  Mnxn(F)

Is tr(A)=trace(A) a member of the feild F? (Does it have to be a member of the feild?)

Just to be sure you got it, ill explain it in another way:

When you calculate tr(A) (when summing the numbers) do you refer to the members ai,i  As normal numbers with the normal "+" function we all know, or add them like you add members of the feild (if in the feild 0=2 then 2+2=2)

Ehrlich  Mar 25, 2017
Sort:

#1
+26365
+2

Did I fail you last time?!!!

I haven't checked, and it's a long time since I did this sort of thing, but:

1. I think it wouldn't make sense to use anything other than the field's own definition of addition in calculating the trace (sum of diagonal elements).

2. Hence the trace must be a member of the field.

If the answer is important then you should double check this with someone more qualified to answer!

Alan  Mar 25, 2017
#2
+310
-1

Then ive misunderstood my professor.

Â

he said he can prove that if F is a field, Char(F)=0, A matrix =Â  Mnxm(F), BÂ matrix =Â  Mmxn(F),

Â

AB=In

Â

And

Â

BA=Im

Â

Then A is Â aÂ square matrix.

Â

his way: at the beggining he proved that ifÂ A matrix =Â  Mnxm(F), BÂ matrix =Â  Mmxn(F) then tr(AB)=tr(BA).

Â

then he said n=tr(In)=tr(AB)=tr(BA)=tr(Im)=m then n=m

Â

BUT HE DIDNT EVEN USE THE FACT CHAR(F)=0 AND HE SAID ITS HARD TO PROVE IT WITHOUT HAVING THE FACT CHAR(F)=0. I KNOW I MISUNDERSTOOD HIM BUT MY QUESTION IS WHERE. ITS FREAKING ME OUT.

Â

by the way, what are you doing nowadays? are you a professor or something?

Ehrlich  Mar 25, 2017
#3
+310
-1

Then ive misunderstood my professor.

he can prove that if F is a field, Char(F)=0, A matrix = Â Mnxm(F), B matrix = Â Mmxn(F),

AB=In

And

BA=Im

Then A is Â aÂ square matrix.

his way: at the beggining he proved that ifÂ A matrix =Â  Mnxm(F), BÂ matrix =Â  Mmxn(F) then tr(AB)=tr(BA).

then he said n=tr(In)=tr(AB)=tr(BA)=tr(Im)=m then n=m

BUT HE DIDNT EVEN USE THE FACT CHAR(F)=0 AND HE SAID ITS HARD TO PROVE IT WITHOUT HAVING THE FACT CHAR(F)=0. I KNOW I MISUNDERSTOOD HIM BUT MY QUESTION IS WHERE. ITS FREAKING ME OUT.

by the way, what are you doing nowadays? are you a professor or something?

Â

Â

Â

sorry i resent it because something fucked up for some reason

Ehrlich  Mar 25, 2017
#4
+26365
0

I'm afraid my knowledge is insufficient here. Perhaps this will help:

I am not and never have been a professor!

Alan  Mar 25, 2017
#5
+310
-1

Then how do you know so much about things and stuff?

What university did you graduate from?

Ehrlich  Mar 25, 2017
#6
+26365
+2

"Then how do you know so much about things and stuff?"

I don't know very much about anything!  I've applied math to real world systems for a long time though.

"What university did you graduate from?"

Warwick University  (in the UK)

Alan  Mar 25, 2017
#7
+310
+1

Atleast there is a reliable source in this site then :D

Ehrlich  Mar 25, 2017

### 33 Online Users

We use cookies to personalise content and ads, to provide social media features and to analyse our traffic. We also share information about your use of our site with our social media, advertising and analytics partners.  See details