+0  
 
0
347
3
avatar

Imagine you have a large supply of 3kg and 8kg weights. Two 3kg weights and three 8kg weights have a mean of 6kg, because (3+3+8+8+8)/5=6 Can you find other combinations of 3kg and 8kg weights whose mean weight is is whole number of kg? What's the smallest? Whats the largest? Can you make all the whole numbers inbetween?cheeky

Guest Feb 4, 2016

Best Answer 

 #2
avatar+18712 
+35

Imagine you have a large supply of 3kg and 8kg weights. Two 3kg weights and three 8kg weights have a mean of 6kg, because (3+3+8+8+8)/5=6 Can you find other combinations of 3kg and 8kg weights whose mean weight is is whole number of kg? What's the smallest? Whats the largest? Can you make all the whole numbers inbetween?

 

Part 2:

 

\(\text{proof}:\\ \begin{array}{rcll} \text{mean } &=& \frac{ u\cdot n \times 3\ kg + v\cdot n \times 8\ kg } { u\cdot n + v\cdot n } \\ &=& \frac{ n\cdot ( u \times 3\ kg + v \times 8\ kg ) } { n\cdot ( u + v ) } \\ &=& \frac{ u \times 3\ kg + v \times 8\ kg } { u + v } \qquad & | \qquad 3\ kg = 8\ kg - 5\ kg \\ &=& \frac{u \times (8\ kg - 5\ kg) + v \times 8\ kg }{ u + v } \\ &=& \frac{u \times (8 - 5 ) + v \times 8} { u + v} \\ &=& \frac{ 8u - 5u + 8v }{ u + v} \\ &=& \frac{ 8(u+v) - 5u}{ u + v} \\ &=& \frac{ 8(u+v) }{ u + v} - \frac{ 5u }{ u + v} \\ &=& 8 - \frac{ 5u }{ u + v} \\ \end{array}\)

 

mean is a whole number, if \(\frac{ 5u }{ u + v}\) is a whole number.

The divisors of 5 is 5 and 1.

So \(\frac{ 5u }{ u + v}\) is a whole number, if \(u+v= 1\) or \(u+v = 5\)

 

1.)  u+v= 1

\(\begin{array}{|rcrcc|ccc|} \hline u && v && u+v & 8 - \frac{ 5u }{ u + v}&& mean \\ \hline 1 &+& 0 & = & 1 & 8 - \frac{ 5\cdot 1 }{ 1 + 0} &=& 3 \\ 0 &+& 1 & = & 1 & 8 - \frac{ 5\cdot 0 }{ 0 + 1} &=& 8 \\ \hline \end{array}\)

 

2.)  u+v= 5

\(\begin{array}{|rcrcc|ccc|} \hline u && v && u+v & 8 - \frac{ 5u }{ u + v}&& mean \\ \hline 1 &+& 4 & = & 5 & 8 - \frac{ 5\cdot 1 }{ 1 + 4} &=& 7 \\ 2 &+& 3 & = & 5 & 8 - \frac{ 5\cdot 2 }{ 2 + 3} &=& 6 \\ 3 &+& 2 & = & 5 & 8 - \frac{ 5\cdot 3 }{ 3 + 2} &=& 5 \\ 4 &+& 1 & = & 5 & 8 - \frac{ 5\cdot 4 }{ 4 + 1} &=& 4 \\ \hline \end{array}\)

 

laugh

heureka  Feb 5, 2016
edited by heureka  Feb 5, 2016
edited by heureka  Feb 5, 2016
Sort: 

3+0 Answers

 #1
avatar+18712 
+35

Imagine you have a large supply of 3kg and 8kg weights.

Two 3kg weights and three 8kg weights have a mean of 6kg, because (3+3+8+8+8)/5=6 .

Can you find other combinations of 3kg and 8kg weights whose mean weight is whole number of kg?

What's the smallest?

Whats the largest?

Can you make all the whole numbers inbetween?

 

\(\begin{array}{|r|r|r|r|} \hline \text{mean} & \text{all combinations} & \text{example combination }~ (n= 1) & \text{example mean }~ (n= 1) \\ \hline 3 & 1\times 3\ kg & \\ 4 & 4\cdot n\times 3\ kg + n\times 8\ kg & 4\cdot 1\times 3\ kg + 1\times 8\ kg & \frac{12+8}{4+1} = 4 \\ 5 & 3\cdot n\times 3\ kg + 2\cdot n\times 8\ kg & 3\cdot 1\times 3\ kg + 2\cdot 1\times 8\ kg & \frac{9+16}{3+2} = 5 \\ 6 & 2\cdot n\times 3\ kg + 3\cdot n\times 8\ kg & 2\cdot 1\times 3\ kg + 3\cdot 1\times 8\ kg & \frac{6+24}{2+3} = 6 \\ 7 & n\times 3\ kg + 4\cdot n\times 8\ kg & 1\times 3\ kg + 4\cdot 1\times 8\ kg & \frac{3+32}{1+4} = 7 \\ 8 & 1\times 8\ kg & \\ \hline \end{array}\)

 

laugh

heureka  Feb 5, 2016
 #2
avatar+18712 
+35
Best Answer

Imagine you have a large supply of 3kg and 8kg weights. Two 3kg weights and three 8kg weights have a mean of 6kg, because (3+3+8+8+8)/5=6 Can you find other combinations of 3kg and 8kg weights whose mean weight is is whole number of kg? What's the smallest? Whats the largest? Can you make all the whole numbers inbetween?

 

Part 2:

 

\(\text{proof}:\\ \begin{array}{rcll} \text{mean } &=& \frac{ u\cdot n \times 3\ kg + v\cdot n \times 8\ kg } { u\cdot n + v\cdot n } \\ &=& \frac{ n\cdot ( u \times 3\ kg + v \times 8\ kg ) } { n\cdot ( u + v ) } \\ &=& \frac{ u \times 3\ kg + v \times 8\ kg } { u + v } \qquad & | \qquad 3\ kg = 8\ kg - 5\ kg \\ &=& \frac{u \times (8\ kg - 5\ kg) + v \times 8\ kg }{ u + v } \\ &=& \frac{u \times (8 - 5 ) + v \times 8} { u + v} \\ &=& \frac{ 8u - 5u + 8v }{ u + v} \\ &=& \frac{ 8(u+v) - 5u}{ u + v} \\ &=& \frac{ 8(u+v) }{ u + v} - \frac{ 5u }{ u + v} \\ &=& 8 - \frac{ 5u }{ u + v} \\ \end{array}\)

 

mean is a whole number, if \(\frac{ 5u }{ u + v}\) is a whole number.

The divisors of 5 is 5 and 1.

So \(\frac{ 5u }{ u + v}\) is a whole number, if \(u+v= 1\) or \(u+v = 5\)

 

1.)  u+v= 1

\(\begin{array}{|rcrcc|ccc|} \hline u && v && u+v & 8 - \frac{ 5u }{ u + v}&& mean \\ \hline 1 &+& 0 & = & 1 & 8 - \frac{ 5\cdot 1 }{ 1 + 0} &=& 3 \\ 0 &+& 1 & = & 1 & 8 - \frac{ 5\cdot 0 }{ 0 + 1} &=& 8 \\ \hline \end{array}\)

 

2.)  u+v= 5

\(\begin{array}{|rcrcc|ccc|} \hline u && v && u+v & 8 - \frac{ 5u }{ u + v}&& mean \\ \hline 1 &+& 4 & = & 5 & 8 - \frac{ 5\cdot 1 }{ 1 + 4} &=& 7 \\ 2 &+& 3 & = & 5 & 8 - \frac{ 5\cdot 2 }{ 2 + 3} &=& 6 \\ 3 &+& 2 & = & 5 & 8 - \frac{ 5\cdot 3 }{ 3 + 2} &=& 5 \\ 4 &+& 1 & = & 5 & 8 - \frac{ 5\cdot 4 }{ 4 + 1} &=& 4 \\ \hline \end{array}\)

 

laugh

heureka  Feb 5, 2016
edited by heureka  Feb 5, 2016
edited by heureka  Feb 5, 2016
 #3
avatar+78618 
+12

Very nice, heureka.....particularly, the proof part.....!!!!

 

 

 

cool cool cool

CPhill  Feb 6, 2016

9 Online Users

avatar
avatar
We use cookies to personalise content and ads, to provide social media features and to analyse our traffic. We also share information about your use of our site with our social media, advertising and analytics partners.  See details