Original rectangle L*W = A
New rectangle (L-1)*(W+1) = A + x
L*W + L - W - 1 = A + x
or L - W - 1 = x since L*W = A
If x has to be a positive integer as well then:
When L-W = 2 units, x = 1 square unit
If x doesn't have to be an integer then there it has no smallest value (it can be infinitesimally small).
.