OMG! I USED TO FEEL LIKE THAT TOO! (Keywords:USED TO)
I was originally doing Kumon, and I felt like I couldn't get any farther with Kumon, so I quit at level H. I then discovered alcumus, like you. My dad encouraged me to do alcumus, and mathcounts trainer as well, and one day, we found out a way to enroll in CLASSES on AOPS. There are SEVERAL different classes, like algebra A and B, intro to Geom, AMC 8, 10, and 12 classes, number theory, probability and counting, etc. I feel like the classes REALLY helped. Tbh, I am only 11, I just REALLY like math, (spend like 1 hour on here a day, 30 minutes school math, another 30 minutes for class homework and alcumus), and I've been improving at an alarming rate. All you have to do is make an account if you haven't already, and look up on your screen, and you will see a few options, hover over online school(If you are on computer. If you are on iOS or android then press it) and select Course catalog. There, you will find a lot of different options of classes. You can press one you feel like doing, and to the right of the summary, there are two links, one to see if you are ready for this class, and one to see if you need it at all. You can keep doing these mini tests, and find one that you are both interested in, and suits you. If there are things you don't understand in the "do I need this" section, then by the end of the course, you will understand it. Hopefully this is helpful, although it is lengthy.