Hey Melody,
I actually didn't mean for the boxed numbers to be on the side like they did, it actually came by accident. Lol!
Maybe you can explain why this happened. I basically just ended the array, then put in the box command and it appeared on the side like so. I was hoping to box the not equal sign that's already centered, but when I tried to box it, it just kept spooling and didn't give me a result in the output box.
The highlighted is what I was trying to box:

Here's my code:
\begin{array}{rll}
4x+5&=&4x-1\\
4(4)+5&=&4(4)-1\\
16+5&=&16-1\\
21&\neq&15
\end{array}
\boxed{21&\neq&15}\\
\begin{array}{rll}
4x+5&=&4x-1\\
4(15)+5&=&4(15)-1\\
60+5&=&60-1\\
65&\neq&59
\end{array}
\boxed{65\neq59}
Any help is appreciated. :)