John draws a regular five pointed star in the sand, and at each of the 5 outward-pointing points and 5 inward-pointing points he places one of ten different sea shells. How many ways can he place the shells, if reflections and rotations of an arrangement are considered equivalent?


Any help is greatly appreciated

Memes4Life132  Jul 21, 2018

Diregarding my previous answer  - I didn't consider that all rotations were the same -  I think this is like the total number of arrangements of 10 people seated at a table...


We place "anchor" any shell in any position.....and we have 9! ways to place the other shells


So...the total arrangements  are 9!  = 362880



cool cool cool

CPhill  Jul 21, 2018

I got the same answer, but i didn't understand your explanation. can you please elaborate?

Guest Jul 21, 2018

Note that we can "anchor" any one of the shells at any of the specified positions....at the next position [ let's assume that we are moving "clockwise" around the star...but..it doesn't matter, we could also move "counter-clockwise" with the same results ], we can choose any  1 of the other 9 shells  =  9 possibilities


Similarly, at the next position, we could choose any 1 of the 8 remaining shells = 8 possibilities


So...continuing this pattern at each successive position we get


9 * 8  * 7 * 6 * 5 *4*3* 2* 1   = 9!  = 362880  arrangements


cool cool cool

CPhill  Jul 21, 2018

16 Online Users

New Privacy Policy

We use cookies to personalise content and advertisements and to analyse access to our website. Furthermore, our partners for online advertising receive information about your use of our website.
For more information: our cookie policy and privacy policy.