+0  
 
0
459
7
avatar+3277 

A Senate committee has 5 Democrats and 5 Republicans. In how many distinguishable ways can they sit around a circular table if all the members of each party all sit next to each other?

tertre  Feb 18, 2018
 #1
avatar+13644 
+1

As a block of 5 and 5 there are 10 ways to sit around the table   10.

  Now , WITHIN  EACH block there is 5! ways to sit

     AND for EACH of the 5! ways to sit in one block there are 5! ways to sit in the OTHER block....

so   10 x 5! x 5! = 144,000 ways

      (I am still learning this stuff like you.....as GA can attest!  So this answer may be incorrect!)     ~EP

ElectricPavlov  Feb 18, 2018
edited by ElectricPavlov  Feb 18, 2018
 #2
avatar+3277 
+1

Here is my solution, EP. Correct me if I'm wrong.....

 

Choose any 5 consecutive seats in which to place the Democrats -- it doesn't matter which 5 consecutive seats that we choose, since we can rotate the table. Then there are 5! ways to place the Democrats in their seats, and 5! ways to place the Republicans in their seats, for a total of 5!*5!=14,400 arrangements.

tertre  Feb 18, 2018
edited by tertre  Feb 18, 2018
 #4
avatar+13644 
0

You may be correct.....I am assuming you can position the democrats and repub blocks 10 different ways araound the table....you are assuming there is only one way (it IS a round table after all).

That is why my answer is 10 times bigger than yours.....I hope someone who KNOWS the answer can chime in, but here is my reasoning (which may be incorrect for a ROUND table with no reference point.....but ok for a rectangular table....just dont know)

  I suspect YOUR answer is correct as far as ORDER of the people go as you go around the table....but if the table is referenced as in my diagram to North...or the door of the room or the window in the room etc, then does the answer change?

  What would happen if there were 11 chairs? (I think THAT would make my answer more correct)

 

Learning !

ElectricPavlov  Feb 18, 2018
edited by ElectricPavlov  Feb 18, 2018
edited by ElectricPavlov  Feb 18, 2018
 #5
avatar+3277 
0

You have a point, EP. 

tertre  Feb 18, 2018
 #3
avatar+621 
0

I think that's correct............

mathtoo  Feb 18, 2018
 #6
avatar+91213 
+2

Here's my take

 

Anchor the Republicans in any 5 seats.....note that it doesn't matter which 5 seats they occupy....if rotated, all of the arrangements will look the same......and they can be arranged in 5!  = 120 ways

 

So.....the Democrats  occupy the other 5 seats and they can be arranged in the same muber of ways = 5!  = 120 ways

 

So...the total arrangemets are   (Ways to arrange the Republicans) x ( Ways to arrange the Democrats)  =  120 x 120  =  14,400

 

To see this..let's suppose that we have A,B,C,D  and AB  must sit as a block and CD must sit as a block

 

So  we have  2!  = 2 ways to arrange AB  and 2!  = 2 ways to arrange CD  = 2! x 2!  =  4 total  arrangements

 

So.....the arrangements are

 

     A                             A                     B                    B

C       B                   D       B            C      A            D     A

    D                             C                     D                    C

 

Note that any rotations will still look the same with regards to order

 

 

cool cool cool

CPhill  Feb 18, 2018
edited by CPhill  Feb 18, 2018
 #7
avatar+3277 
0

Fabulous work, CPhill! It's above amazing! 

tertre  Feb 18, 2018

23 Online Users

avatar
avatar
avatar

New Privacy Policy

We use cookies to personalise content and advertisements and to analyse access to our website. Furthermore, our partners for online advertising receive information about your use of our website.
For more information: our cookie policy and privacy policy.