+0  
 
0
272
5
avatar

prove that x^15+x^5+2=0, do not have positive roots?

Guest Sep 28, 2014

Best Answer 

 #5
avatar+91505 
+5

Thanks Geno,

I am just going to work through my version of your logic.  :)

$$\\x^{15}+x^5+2=0\\\\
Let\;\;y=x^5\\\\
y^3+y+2=0\\\\
y(y^2+1)=-2\\\\
y^2+1 $ must be positive so $y$ must be negative. Hence$\\\\
x^5$ must be negative, hence $\\\\
x $ must be negative$\\\\
$Therefore, no positive roots exist.$$$

Melody  Sep 29, 2014
Sort: 

5+0 Answers

 #1
avatar
0

prove that x^15+x^5+2=0, do not have positive roots?

 

Let's write x^5 = y

Then we get:

y^3 +y +2 = 0

 

y^3 +y = -2

 

y(1 +y^2) = -2 

 

y =-2 or y^2 +1 =-2

 

 

We solve y^2 +1 =-2

 

y^2 = -3

 

y doesn't have any solution among the real numbers R.

 

y = √-3 = √3 *i or -√3 *i

 

To sum it up: y = -2 or y = √3 *i or y = -√3 *i

x^5 = y

 

...

Guest Sep 28, 2014
 #2
avatar+91505 
0

Let's write x^5 = y     good idea

Then we get:

y^3 +y +2 = 0

 y^3 +y = -2

 y(1 +y^2) = -2       Yes

 y =-2 or y^2 +1 =-2       WHY?

Melody  Sep 28, 2014
 #3
avatar
+5

You are right, Melody!

 

I must have been asleep :P

 

 

Ok, I'll try once more:

 

 

Let's write x^5 = y

Then we get:

y^3 +y +2 = 0

 

y^3 +y = -2

 

y(1 +y^2) = -2 

 

Ok, we know that:

y^2 +1 = (y- i)(y+i)

 

I'm not really sure from here :(

Guest Sep 28, 2014
 #4
avatar+17711 
+5

I would argue that if you want the equation to have a positive root, then x must be positive.

But if x is positive, then both x^15 is positive and x^5 is positive.

Adding two positive number to the number 2, your answer must be positive; thus, it can't be zero.

(proof by contradiction)

geno3141  Sep 28, 2014
 #5
avatar+91505 
+5
Best Answer

Thanks Geno,

I am just going to work through my version of your logic.  :)

$$\\x^{15}+x^5+2=0\\\\
Let\;\;y=x^5\\\\
y^3+y+2=0\\\\
y(y^2+1)=-2\\\\
y^2+1 $ must be positive so $y$ must be negative. Hence$\\\\
x^5$ must be negative, hence $\\\\
x $ must be negative$\\\\
$Therefore, no positive roots exist.$$$

Melody  Sep 29, 2014

7 Online Users

avatar
We use cookies to personalise content and ads, to provide social media features and to analyse our traffic. We also share information about your use of our site with our social media, advertising and analytics partners.  See details