+0  
 
+5
834
1
avatar

Step 1: Let a=b.

  • Step 2: Then  (IMAGE) ,
  • Step 3:  (IMAGE) ,
  • Step 4:  (IMAGE) ,
  • Step 5:  (IMAGE) ,
  • Step 6: and  (IMAGE) .

     

  • Step 7: This can be written as  (IMAGE) ,
  • Step 8: and cancelling the  (IMAGE) from both sides gives 1=2.
  • See if you can figure out in which step the fallacy lies. When you think you've figured it out, click on that step and the computer will tell you whether you are correct or not, and will give an additional explanation of why that step is or isn't valid.

    See how many tries it takes you to correctly identify the fallacious step!

    source:https://www.math.toronto.edu/mathnet/falseProofs/first1eq2.html

 Jul 7, 2014
 #1
avatar+109783 
0

Thanks Anonymous,

If I didn't look at every question when I write a wrap I would have missed this.

Thanks for sharing.

I will put it in with our puzzles too I think.   

 Jul 10, 2014

27 Online Users

avatar
avatar
avatar