+0  
 
0
869
5
avatar

tan^-1(16/x)=90; x = ABC. Other calculators show that there are no answers possible. I would like to know why, thank you in advance.

 Jun 14, 2015

Best Answer 

 #1
avatar+33657 
+15

This says that 16/x = tan(90°).  But tan(90°) is undefined.  The limit of tan(θ) as θ approaches 90° from above is -∞; the limit as θ approaches 90° from below is +∞.  

Hence there is no value of x for which tan-1(16/x) = 90°

.

 Jun 14, 2015
 #1
avatar+33657 
+15
Best Answer

This says that 16/x = tan(90°).  But tan(90°) is undefined.  The limit of tan(θ) as θ approaches 90° from above is -∞; the limit as θ approaches 90° from below is +∞.  

Hence there is no value of x for which tan-1(16/x) = 90°

.

Alan Jun 14, 2015
 #2
avatar
0

It's a limiting thing, but I suppose that you could argue that x = 0 is a solution.

 Jun 14, 2015
 #3
avatar+118667 
+5

It is not phrased as a limiting question anon.  

And if it was it would have to be also have to be stated as "from the positive side"

Hence there is no answer.

 Jun 14, 2015
 #4
avatar
0

Thank you all.

 Jun 14, 2015
 #5
avatar
0

I did say ' that you could argue that '... .

 

If the 'function' mentioned in the question were tan, then the discontinuity at pi/2 would make it unreasonable to talk about the limit without further information as to whether we were approaching from below or above.

 

However, the 'function' mentioned in the question is the inverse tangent arctan. This is multivalued and if you take usual view of working within the principal range, there is no discontinuity. Asking what happens to the inverse tangent as its argument tends to infinity is quite reasonable.

 Jun 15, 2015

0 Online Users