We use cookies to personalise content and advertisements and to analyse access to our website. Furthermore, our partners for online advertising receive pseudonymised information about your use of our website.
Please click on "Accept cookies" if you agree to the setting of cookies. Cookies that do not require consent remain unaffected by this, see
cookie policy and privacy policy.
DECLINE COOKIES

A rectangular box with a square bottom and closed top is to be made from two materials. The material for the side costs $1.50 per square foot and the material for the top and bottom costs $3.00 per square foot. If you are willing to spend $15 on the box, what is the largest volume it can contain? Justify your answer completely using calculus.

If anyone can give step-by-step instructions on how to do this problem, I would really appreciate it. Thanks in advance.

gibsonj338 Jan 9, 2019

#1**+4 **

\(\text{the wording is kind of odd. Is the bottom open? Sort of a weird way to orient the problem if so}\\ \text{I'm going to assume both the top and bottom are closed}\\ \text{we've got the two different types of materials so let's compute the two areas separately}\\ \text{assume the box has square side length }s \text{ and height }h\\ area_{side}=4sh\\ area_{tb} = 2s^2\\ vol = s^2h\)

\(\text{we can convert areas into cost using the materials prices}\\ C = 4sh\cdot (1.5) + 2s^2 \cdot (3) = 6sh + 6s^2\)

\(\text{I"m going to assume you haven't been taught Lagrange multipliers yet}\\ \text{so we have to use the cost function to write the volume in a single variable}\\ 15 = 6sh + 6s^2\\ h = \dfrac{15-6s^2}{6s}\\ vol = s^2 h = s^2\dfrac{15-6s^2}{6s} = \dfrac{15s-6s^3}{6}\)

\(\text{Now to find the extrema of the volume we set it's derivative equal to 0}\\ \dfrac{dvol}{ds} = \dfrac{15-18s^2}{6} =\dfrac{ 5-6s^2}{2} = 0\\ 5 = 6s^2\\ s = \sqrt{\dfrac 5 6}~ft \text{ (we can ignore the negative solution)}\)

\(vol = \dfrac 1 6 \left(15\sqrt{\dfrac 5 6} -6 \left(\dfrac 5 6\right)^{3/2}\right) = \dfrac 5 3 \sqrt{\dfrac 5 6}~ft^3\)

.Rom Jan 10, 2019

#3**+2 **

The top is closed per the question....but it does not say if it is the same material as the bottom.....just states BOTTOM is 3/sqft.....

I'm glad you got an answer! I got stuck when I tried top made of same material as sides and only bottom at $3/sqft. ~EP

ElectricPavlov
Jan 10, 2019

#2**+2 **

\(\text{What's that? Lagrange multipliers?}\\ \text{The method of Lagrange multipliers involves solving}\\ \nabla (f(s,h) - \lambda (c(s,h)-C))\\ \text{In this problem }\\ f(s,h) = vol(s,h) = s^2 h\\ c(s,h)=6sh+6s^2 (\text{see the previous answer})\\ C=15\)

\(\text{our Lagrange equation becomes}\\ \nabla \left(s^2 h - \lambda (6sh-6s^2 - 15)\right)= (0,0,0)\\ \text{this leads to the system of equations }\\ 2sh - \lambda(6h - 12s)=0\\ s^2 - 6s\lambda = 0\\ 6sh-6s^2-15 = 0\\\)

\(\text{and these are solved for }s,~h,~\lambda\\ \text{This seems like a lot more work than the previous answer. Why do it?}\\ \text{In most problems you can't cleanly solve for one in terms of the other and substitute like we did}\)

.Rom Jan 10, 2019

#4**+1 **

Let the volume be

V = x^2*h where x is the side of the base and h is the height (1)

And.....using the total cost for the surface area....we know that

Total cost for top/ bottom + Total cost for sides = 15

2x^2(3) + 4xh(1.5) = 15

15 - 6x^2 = 6xh

[ 15 - 6x^2] / [6x] = h (2)

Put (2) into (1) and we have that

V = x^2 [ 15 - 6x^2] / [ 6x]

V = x [ 15 - 6x^2] / 6

V = (1/6) (15x - 6x^3 ) take the derivative and set to 0

(1/6) (15 - 18x^2) = 0

18x^2 = 15

x^2 = 15/18 = 5/6

x = √[5/6]

So.....the volume of the box is : (1/6)√[5/6] (15 -6 (5/6) ) = (1/6)√[5/6] (10) = (5/3)√[5/6] ft^3

CPhill Jan 10, 2019