+0  
 
0
80
5
avatar+554 

Hey guys, it's been a while since I posted a question.

I have a problem. I can't really seem to figure out if a situation requires a permutation or combination type of solving. 

Here's the question. Please explain...

 

A football competition is organised between 8 teams. In how many ways can the top 4 places be filled in order of premiership points obtained? 

 

The answer is 1680. To get this answer you need to do: 8*7*6*5

 

This is for permutation. For combination, you'll have to divide this by 4*3*2*1.

 

What do I have to do, and why?

Thanks

Gh0sty15  Aug 3, 2018
 #1
avatar
+1

Isn't it a simple case of permutations and combinations???

 

Permutations =8 nPr 4 =8! / (8 - 4)! =40,320 / 24 =1,680

 

Combinations =8 nCr 4 = 8! / [(8 - 4)! * 4!]=40,320 / (24 x 24) =70

Guest Aug 3, 2018
 #2
avatar+554 
+1

Yeah. But I wanted to know how to find out if this situation was a permutation or combination (without knowing the answer)

When there are 4 out of 8 teams that are going to fill out the top 4, is it a permutation or combination? And why? 

 

Does top 4 mean there is an order? Because that would mean it would be a permutation.

Or does top 4 means any random team can enter? Because that would mean it would be a combination (I think...)

Thanks though!

Gh0sty15  Aug 3, 2018
 #3
avatar
+1

Permutation: A set of objects in which position (or order) is 
important. Example: a,b, c, d

{a, b, c, d} | {a, b, d, c} | {a, c, b, d} | {a, c, d, b} | {a, d, b, c} | {a, d, c, b} | {b, a, c, d} | {b, a, d, c} | {b, c, a, d} | {b, c, d, a} | {b, d, a, c} | {b, d, c, a} | {c, a, b, d} | {c, a, d, b} | {c, b, a, d} | {c, b, d, a} | {c, d, a, b} | {c, d, b, a} | {d, a, b, c} | {d, a, c, b} | {d, b, a, c} | {d, b, c, a} | {d, c, a, b} | {d, c, b, a} (total: 24)

 


Combination: A set of objects in which position (or order) is NOT 
important. Example:a,b, c,d =1 combination only. The order of the letters DOES NOT MATTER.

Guest Aug 3, 2018
 #4
avatar+554 
+1

Oh. But isn't "abcd" one combination as well in a permutation? There isn't another "abcd"

Gh0sty15  Aug 3, 2018
 #5
avatar
+2

Both of them start with: a,b,c, d. But, in permutation, you can move the LETTERS around. So, a,b, c, d is NOT the same as: a, c, b, d. They are 2 different permutations.

 

But in combinations, a,b, c, d AND a, c, b, d ARE THE SAME.

Look at it this way. If there are 4 people, Alice, Bob, Carol, and Dave.

In combinations, no matter how they stand together for a picture, they are considered ONE combination.

But for permutations, you can move them around for a picture. And EACH move is considered a different permutation such as: Alice, Dave, Carol, Bob.

So, you can move them around 4! =24 times for 24 different pictures, or 24 different permutations.

Guest Aug 3, 2018

8 Online Users

avatar

New Privacy Policy

We use cookies to personalise content and advertisements and to analyse access to our website. Furthermore, our partners for online advertising receive information about your use of our website.
For more information: our cookie policy and privacy policy.