+0  
 
0
623
1
avatar

why in the equation (x^2-3x)/(x^2+1)=2 can't i cross out the x^2s to get -3x/1=2 (ofc without the x it doesnt make sense but logically cant you cross the identical numerator and denominator parts out)?

 Sep 6, 2015
 #1
avatar+130513 
+5

We could only do that if we had this :

 

[x^2 * -3x] / [x^2  * 1 ] = 2     →   -3x = 2

 

To see why we can't do what you suggest....let's look at this, instead

 

 

[7 - 2] / [ 7  + 5]      if we "crossed out" the "7s" ???   ....we would end up with  -2/5

 

But.......

 

 

[7 - 2] / [7 + 5]   = 5/12      and that's not -2/5

 

Thus....the rule is....we can cancel multiplication on top and bottom, but not addition/subtraction

 

Does that make sense ???

 

 

Plus....look at what would be  your solution....x = -2/3....see if that works in the original problem.....[it won't   !!! ]

 

 

 

cool cool cool

 Sep 6, 2015

3 Online Users