+0

# Wonky Calculator

+5
388
5

Hey,

I am working with a TI-89 calculator, on this problem:

(−27)^2/3

So this is what I did.  I know that (x^a)^b = x^(ab), so I didn't think that the order of the exponents mattered.

First try: (-27^1/3)^2 = -3^2

At -3^2 I could type this into my calculator, or I could type -3*-3.

-3^2 = -9 but -3*-3 = 9

Second try (I ran into the same kind of problem): (-27^2)^1/3

-27^2 = -729 but -27*-27 = 729

I'm pretty sure that two negatives multiplied equals a positive, but what is my calculator doing?  I would greatly appreciate anyone's help!

Guest Oct 26, 2015

#4
+5

It is definitely wrong!. When squaring a negative number, it should give you a positive answer. Even when raising ANY negative integer to an ODD integer, it should give you a negative answer. Just to get around these problems, you might consider removing the - from the number, and see if it will give the expected answer, and then place the - sign in front of the answer, manually.

Guest Oct 26, 2015
Sort:

#1
+5

I'm not familiar with TI-89 calculator. But you should know that most calculators will not allow you to raise a negative number to any fraction, because (-27)^2/3=(-27^2)^1/3=-729^1/3, which means you are taking the 3rd root of negative number, which most calculators cannot do. Taking any root of a negative number is considered a "complex operation", which involves square root of -1 or i. In fact, the answer to your question is=9 (-1)^(2/3), in complex operation.

Guest Oct 26, 2015
#2
+5

I didn't realize that.  But it is the only way I can find the square cube (raising the number to the 1/3), because my calculator doesn't have a cube root button.  This calculator is also pretty old, so I don't know if it changes anything, but thanks for the input!

But am I right in thinking that it's doing something wierd when I square a negative number and I get another negative number?  (That was my original question)

Guest Oct 26, 2015
edited by Guest  Oct 26, 2015
#3
0

(?27)^2/3

there

Guest Oct 26, 2015
#4
+5

It is definitely wrong!. When squaring a negative number, it should give you a positive answer. Even when raising ANY negative integer to an ODD integer, it should give you a negative answer. Just to get around these problems, you might consider removing the - from the number, and see if it will give the expected answer, and then place the - sign in front of the answer, manually.

Guest Oct 26, 2015
#5
+91780
+5

(-27^1/3)^2 = -3^2

Taking fractional powers of negative numbers often causes problems for calculators.

(Often it really does not makes sence for people either.  Though a good example escapes me at present.)

Even new and fancy calcs have problems.

I am sure some people here understand and can explain it a lot better than me.

\((27^{2/3})\\ =(27^2)^{1/3}=729^{1/3}=9\\ =(27^{1/3})^2=3^2=9\\\)

\((-27)^{2/3} \\ ((-27)^2)^{1/3}=729^{1/3}=+9\\ ((-27)^{1/3})^2=(-3)^2=+9\)

I do not agree with something the first guest said.   This statement is inaccurate because brackets have been left out.

(-27)^2/3=(-27^2)^1/3=-729^1/3,

It should be

(-27)^2/3=([-27]^2)^1/3=+729^1/3 = +9

Melody  Oct 27, 2015

### 26 Online Users

We use cookies to personalise content and ads, to provide social media features and to analyse our traffic. We also share information about your use of our site with our social media, advertising and analytics partners.  See details