+0  
 
0
931
9
avatar+1832 

How can I draw a free body diagram for this question ? 

 

 Sep 19, 2015

Best Answer 

 #2
avatar+33614 
+15

I think your free body diagrams are like this (you'll need to fill in the distances yourself):

 

free body diagrams

 

Correction:  The top force for BE should say RE not RD

Another correction:  In the free body diagram of AC the force RC is pointing up when it should be pointing down!

 Sep 19, 2015
edited by Alan  Sep 19, 2015
edited by Alan  Sep 20, 2015
 #1
avatar
0

Alan, one of the moderators might be able to help you in this physics question, but is not online right now.

 Sep 19, 2015
 #2
avatar+33614 
+15
Best Answer

I think your free body diagrams are like this (you'll need to fill in the distances yourself):

 

free body diagrams

 

Correction:  The top force for BE should say RE not RD

Another correction:  In the free body diagram of AC the force RC is pointing up when it should be pointing down!

Alan Sep 19, 2015
edited by Alan  Sep 19, 2015
edited by Alan  Sep 20, 2015
 #3
avatar+1832 
0

On rod AC , why we didn't consider the reaction at the top of rod BE ? 

 Sep 19, 2015
 #4
avatar+33614 
+5

Because a free body diagram only considers the forces acting directly on the (free) body in question.  The only force acting on AC from BE is RB 

 Sep 19, 2015
 #5
avatar+1832 
0

Very well, now for member BE what is Rd and Rb ? 

 Sep 20, 2015
 #6
avatar+33614 
+10

I think the following is probably what is needed (but you should check it carefully!).

 

Note:  The force on top of BE should be labelled RE not RD (which was a typo by me).  It will be the same in magnitude as RB

 

forces

 

.

 Sep 20, 2015
edited by Alan  Sep 20, 2015
edited by Alan  Sep 20, 2015
edited by Alan  Sep 20, 2015
 #7
avatar+1832 
0

Yes Alan, you answer is correct. 

But I still have some problems with the free body diagram. 

 

1 - What is Rc ? is this the shear force ?? 

2- Is RE is the reaction of the support in beam BE ? 

3- What is RB in the beam BE ? 

 

those are my three questions and I will fully understand this problem.  

 Sep 21, 2015
 #8
avatar+33614 
+5

1 - What is Rc ? is this the shear force ?? 

In the free-body diagram for CD, RC is the net force on CD due to AC (i.e. AC is helping to support CD and keep it from going down).

In the free-body diagram for AC, RC is the reaction of CD on AC (Newton's 3rd law of motion).

 

 

2- Is RE is the reaction of the support in beam BE ? 

Yes, in free-body diagram BE, RE is the force of the support at E on BE.  

 

 

3- What is RB in the beam BE ? 

In free-body diagram BE, RB is the force of AC on BE (i.e. AC is trying to pull BE down).

In free-body diagram AC, RB is the reaction force of BE on AC (i.e. BE is trying to keep AC up - Newton's 3rd law again).

 

Hope this helps.

 Sep 21, 2015
 #9
avatar+1832 
0

Your answer is amazing. 

Thank you Alan. 

 Sep 22, 2015

5 Online Users

avatar
avatar
avatar