Questions   
Sort: 
 #15
avatar+2489 
+10

Asinus is right, this is debated quite often in academic circles –at least among the science and math majors.

 

I’ll add another two cents worth.

 

A fraction is ostensibly the same as division.  Most will agree that all of these are the same thing the same as  

\(3 \div 5 \\ \dfrac {3}{5}\\ 3/5 \\\)

Most will also know that order of operations (PEMDAS) says division take precedence over addition. Meaning 5+20/4+1 = 11 (not 5)

 

But

 

\(\dfrac {5+20}{4+1} = 5\)

 

There are no parentheses here, and addition now appears to takes precedence over division --both before and after the division  to give the "correct" answer of 5.

 

(Take note, guest #7, you listed several calculators but left out this site’s calculator)

These are comments from my favorite troll:

 

If you paste this  48/(2)(9+3)  into the site calculator, it returns 2 as the solution.

This is isn’t a bug. The parentheses cause the value to be treated as a variable. Implicit multiplication of variables takes precedents over division – a noted exception, dating back to the late 1960s, to the normal convention of mathematical hierarchy . Herr Massow’s calculator is the only one I know of that that does this, and it’s probably because it allows the use of variables.

 

Of course, if you put the explicit multiplication operator in: 48/(2)*(9+3) or leave the parentheses off the 2 then it returns 288,  the normal solution for numeric values.

 

This calc does have one hierarchal fault. “Stacked powers” are right-associated. The calc resolves them from the left.

4^3^2 returns (4^3)^2 = 4096 (It shows the order at the top).

With the correct hierarchy, it is 262144.

 

It’s always a good idea to know the quirks and faults of the tools you might use.  I drove an old car once that ran great, but the breaks didn’t work so well –I had to drag my foot to help it stop. It sure wore out my shoes faster than normal. :)

Dec 23, 2016

3 Online Users

avatar