Questions   
Sort: 
 #3
avatar+2489 
+6

Guest #1 is correct. You do need to add Earth’s radius to this distance – it is part of the “trickiness” needed to solve it.  I made the same mistake. My mentor caught it and asked me if I thought a satellite orbiting the Earth once every 78 seconds might seem a little fast?

 

-------

Last year, my professor assigned this question as one of several related homework questions for my Physics for non-majors class.  The question asked for the gravitational force, orbital velocity, and period.  After completing the assignment, I sent it to my mentor for review.  After a few error corrections, the Troll Master said I should ask my professor about the use of the Titan IV. 

 

I reworded his rhetorical comments and wrote them on a post-it note attached to my homework:

 

I know this is a hypothetical question and it’s irrelevant how the satellite obtained its orbit, but why would the engineers use a $450 million Titan IV, capable of placing 12 times the payload in that orbit, when a $51 million Delta II could easily do this?

 

This class was usually taught by an undergrad, but my professor replied:

 

Ginger,

 

This was a government sponsored launch and spending 10 to 20 times more than necessary is par for the course.  In fact, the engineers might have received a bonus for keeping costs down.  

After 8 years of teaching physics classes, you have the unique distinction of being the first physics’ troll in the non-majors class.  You’ve renewed my hope for the modern world. 

----

 

LancelotLink told me this was a great accolade and I should put it on my resume. smiley

 

Before I met my favorite troll, the only humor I could ever see in physics was in the “Big Bang Theory.”

Oct 14, 2016

2 Online Users

avatar
avatar